Are Breast Implants Fat Phobic?

I would rather travel than have big boobs.

I would rather travel and contribute to my pension fund than have big boobs.

I enjoy looking at bare breasts in the change room at my gym. I do it brazenly, out of curiosity. I am constantly amazed by how many women have breast implants these days, especially women who appear to be in their early 20s. These young ladies shelled out a lot of money (whether their cash or somebody else’s), undergoing the risks and pain of surgery simply to make their breasts look larger. I know that some women require treatment after experiencing cancer and others are transitioning, but these particular circumstances do not seem to apply to my change room ladies. I think about all the other ways they could have spent that money, including a lengthy trip through Europe, stopping in Spain to eat oranges in a sunny park before returning to a small hotel with a tiny pink bath tub. That is what I was doing with my scanty earnings when I was 26. At that age, I spent my money on education, travel, rent, and food, working very hard to avoid going into debt. Maybe these young women actually took out loans in order to change their appearance? I just don’t get it.

Gel filled breast implants

Gel filled breast implants

I have tried to understand the allure of breast implants, reading books about the history of breasts, cosmetic surgery, and female body ideals. I have found sociological and feminist articles that simply ask women why they wanted breast implants. The answers are not very revealing [aside: I will save my critiques of social science research methdologies for another day], but most of the women reported that they got implants for “themselves” and simply wanted to be “normal.” Now I am not sure what is their version of a normal female body. Perhaps they have watched quite a bit of pornographic material, especially the conventional kind aimed at straight men. When I look around the change room I see numerous “normal” female bodies and they all look different. Some are big, some are small, some are pale, some are dark, some have long legs, some have tiny waists, some have no waists at all. In terms of breasts, there is a similarly wide range of shapes and sizes, but many have one thing in common—that is, the ones that have not been surgically opened and stuffed with gel packs: they are subject to the laws of gravity. Unaltered breasts (please note that I do not say “natural”) tend to be soft and to move and shift along with the person who grew them. In contrast, the gel pack ones defy gravity in an amazing way, being other than flesh and refusing to age (except when they gradually harden and need to be replaced every ten or fifteen years).

I think that breast implants are part of the culture of fat phobia. Sure, there are many reasons for the increasing number of breast implant surgeries—and one psychological study showed that the women seeking surgery had higher rates of alcoholism, drug use, and suicidal thoughts; their self-esteem improved after the surgeries, giving them potentially better futures (Archives of International Medicine, 2004; Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 2006). But I insist that another part of the current fashion for implants is the general loathing of body fat in western and other cultures. Breasts are primarily composed of fat, so thin women tend to have small breasts and voluptous women tend to have large breasts. It is not very common for lean and muscular women to have big boobs, one of the reasons why competitive female bodybuilders get breast implants in order to re-establish their femininity. The current demand for women to have “toned” lean frames with larges breasts and asses is essentially impossible for the vast majority of women. No amount of working out or dieting will produce the desired result. It is no wonder that breast and butt implants are the most popular kinds: they solve this impossibility while replacing the feel and sensation of fat with a substance that is harder and firmer. In the end, these implants contribute to the widespread hatred of female fat, whether that result is intentional by those who pay for them or not. [For my earlier thoughts on implants, see a post called “Bad Tits,” published on September 30, 2012].

I think the idea that breast implants are fueled by fat phobia is obvious. When I googled this concept, however, I found practically nothing written about it. Instead, I hit a Web site that promoted the injection of fat into female breasts, displaced from other parts of the body ( You can turn your fat thighs into larger breasts, supposedly. This technique does not seem widespread, but would counter my arguments about implants being fat phobic because the technique increases or at least displaces body fat instead of replacing it with another substance. All the same, I have to ask: how many women would prefer this solution to the more common use of artificial implants? Would they be happy with larger, soft and floppy breasts? Or do they want breasts that are in fact composed of something other than fat? I suspect that the latter is the case.

Is this discussion even important? I am not sure. These days, I am focused on trying to live in a less selfish way, reading every day about the tragic plight of Syrian and other refugees. How can I continue to work out at the gym and write about “body image” issues when millions of people are suffering and dying? Their plight puts things in perspective, but it has not diminished the demand for big, round, non-fat breasts. Although I still care about the appearance of my own body, I find that concern—which has never been primary in my life—diminishing further wth age. I recentlly turned 48 and my own breasts are smaller and softer, after their valiant service in feeding my infant son for 7 months. When I was breast feeding, I had large, hard, round “porn” tits. I absolutely hated them. They were unwieldy, heavy, uncomfortable. I had to wear two tight bras at the gym and it still hurt to skip rope. When I see the young women with implants at the gym, I am baffled because I simultaneously see discomfort, pain, and a misplaced effort to create a meaningful life. Perhaps I have gone too far. I expect there will be some push back on this judgemental way of thinking, and I welcome it. I remain open to other interpretations.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , by feministfiguregirl. Bookmark the permalink.

About feministfiguregirl

I am a 51-year-old professor named Lianne McTavish who receives as much satisfaction from working out at the gym as from publishing my academic research. About eight years ago, I decided to combine my two primary identities (scholar/gym rat) to create "Feminist Figure Girl," a fictional character who both analyzes and participates in bodybuilding. I competed in my first figure show in June of 2011, and then wrote a book inspired by the process, published by SUNY Press in February 2015. In this blog I will write about and consider my ongoing research on the body, while regularly making fun of myself. I recommend that you start reading my first post from August 2010 (available on the home page), instead of backwards from the most recent one, in order to get the full FFG effect.

7 thoughts on “Are Breast Implants Fat Phobic?

  1. I found this really interesting. I got breast augmentation at the age of 22 (I’m 26 now and I think I should have waited, to be honest, but, it is what it is). I was very lean at the time and lost what little breast tissue I had. I never had big breasts to begin with. And yes, I did it for me. However, I go back and forth. Some days, I wish I had tiny boobs again. Other days, I love my boobs. And yet, very few days, but it still occurs, I want bigger boobs. I admire all kinds of breasts. Real ones, fake ones, small, big. I just like boobs. Lol!

    Mine do look fake, but they also act very “natural”. Obviously, they aren’t going to sag like unaltered breasts, but they do move with my body, they’ll eventually sag in their own way too. They jiggle like my unaltered breasts did. In fact, I can’t even make my boobs look “porn-star” ish. And this has to do with the type of implant used, the placement, etc.

    However, I’ve since regained a lot of weight and my boobs are a bit too large. lol!

    The hardening of implants is not always the case. This can happen, but doesn’t happen to everyone. It can be very painful and cause a lot of problems or it can never cause any problems, or it may not occur at all.

    I, too, wonder about all of the things I could have spent that money on, but like I said, it is what it is. I can’t go back and change that.

    The thing about fat transfer is, the fat ends up dying. You can only go up a cup size usually and that’s not always a given. It also seems to diminish over time. But, I still think that this contributes to fat phobia-because, as women, we KNOW breasts are purely fat tissue. So, if you want bigger breasts, what’s wrong with fat there? Haven’t you heard women joke about only gaining weight in their boobs? You also can’t get the really “fake” look with fat transfer. You are limited to looking fairly “natural”.

    I’m still working on self-image and body acceptance and sometimes I wonder if I’ll ever get there. Who knows? Also, I’m not in pain. Sure, they get in the way sometimes, certain things might hurt, but no more than the pain/discomfort I felt with unaltered breasts-just slightly different.

    So, I’m sure that I contribute to fat phobia, but this is something that I’ve been conditioned and grown up with. It’s something that I am trying to fight against. However, I think my decision to get breast implants has nothing to do with being lean or fat. I would have gotten them had I not been so lean in the first place, just because I wanted larger breasts. Whether that is fat phobic is subjective and depends on the person.

    Interesting thoughts. Thanks for the discussion!

  2. A really thoughtful post.

    The whole culture of fat phobia is so widespread and pervasive I wouldn’t know where to begin with it. For starters, we just don’t see typical bodies in the media any more, so it becomes increasingly easy to view our own bodies as abnormal.

    Then there’s the whole issue of women’s clothing, where once you hit a certain size (which is not very large) you’re forced into the “plus” sizes (read: leper colony of fashion) and made to feel even more abnormal than you already do. I don’t think it helps that so many of our fashion designers are gay men with, I suspect (dare I even say it?), a loathing of real woman and the female form. I don’t think it’s coincidence that our top models resemble prepubescent boys more than they do the typical woman on the street these days.

    I don’t know what the answer is. More women creating media, certainly, and more women creating fashion *for* women, absolutely. Beyond that, I don’t have answers. In the meanwhile, I’ll do my best to give my daughter a healthy sense of self and try to raise her as an individual who never doubts her own self-worth and unique beauty, and who will never feel the need to insert plastic into her body to become “beautiful”.

    • Thanks for your reply lethally. I have never been interested in fashion, but I don’t know any gay men who hate women. In my experience, gay men are positive supporters of women. In any case, I don’t like to generalize about groups of diverse people.

  3. I dont think its necessarily fat phobia. Some girls like me will never have a curvy figure even if i were fat. I could gain 30lbs of fat and *maybe* go up one cup size. I dont need to ne a size 2, but i would like to change my proportions.

  4. I don’t agree with you at all, really! I am a FAT GIRL! And I want big fat perky breasts! I’m obv not riddled with fat phobia… at all! I like my almost exactly the way it is. Besides these tube socks I now have for titties after losing 50/60 lbs post high school only to regain it 4 years later with child birth. Then almost completely losing them after breastfeeding ended. I want implant and I would even be happy with fat transfer implants the only thing that steers me more towards good ol regular implants over fat transfers is how new the procedure is. I don’t wanna be a ginuea pig! Also with an augmentation I’ll get that perkiness and fullness I once so desperately loved being a teenager or from being 9 months pregnant! If I could achieve perkiness & fullness from a fat transfer be my guest!! I’d gladly pick tinder softness or over something foreign anyway. Brazilian Butt Lifts are way more popular then ass implants cuz it’s natural looking its softer and still gives you the same effect u desire. Soo I’m my opinion, no. Implants is not fat phobia! It’s SAGGY TITTY PHOBIA!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s